Comparison I of Imindfulness Iamong Iadult Ifemales Iperforming Ipilates Ivs Iaerobics

Authors

Saeed Taj Din¹, Saba Salahuddin²

1Associate Professor Orthopaedic Surgery Azra Naheed Medical College Lahore.
2Physical Therapist, Lahore

Article Information

*Corresponding Author: Saeed Taj Din, 1Associate Professor Orthopaedic Surgery Azra Naheed Medical College Lahore.

Received date: January 03, 2023
Accepted date: February 20, 2023
Published date: February 27, 2023

Citation:  Saeed T Din, Salahuddin S. (2023). “Comparison Iof Imindfulness Iamong Iadult Ifemales Iperforming Ipilates Ivs Iaerobics’’. J Orthopaedic Research and Surgery, 4(1); DOI: http;//doi.org/02.2023/1.1033.
Copyright: © 2023 Saeed Taj Din. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Abstract

Background

Pilates iis iform iof iexercise iwhich imainly ifocuses ion imuscle istrengthening iand ihave ia isignificant ieffect ion imindfulness iand iaerobic iexercises iare iused iin iweight itraining iand iweight iloss. iPrevious iresearch iresults isuggested ithat iPilates iare iused ias irehabilitation itool iand iaerobic iexercises iused ito ireduce isocial ianxiety. iSome istudies iconcluded ithat ithey ihave isignificant ibut ishort iterm ieffect ion imindfulness.

Objective

To icompare imindfulness ibetween ifemales iperforming iPilates ivs iaerobic iexercise

Methodology

A icomparative icross isectional istudy iwas iconducted ito ievaluate ithe icomparison iof imindfulness iamong i346 ifemales iperforming iPilates iand iaerobics. iMAAS iquestionnaire iwas iused ito ievaluate ithe icomparison. iReliability iof iMAAS iis i(r=0.04). iSPSS iversion i21 iwas iused ifor ithe ianalysis iof idata.

Results

According ito ithe iresult iof ithe istudy, igroup iperforming iPilates iwere i54% iand iaerobics iwere i46%. iMean iage iof iparticipation iwas ifound i24. iIndependent isample it itest iwas iused ito ievaluate ithe idifference iof imindfulness iamong iwomen iperforming iPilates iand iaerobics. iThere iwas inon-significant idifference iof iaverage imindfulness iscore ibetween itwo igroups. iAlthough igroups iinvolved iin iperforming iPilates ihave islightly imore iaverage imindfulness iscore. iThe iP ivalue iis.228.

Conclusion

This istudy iconcluded ithat ithere iis inon-significant idifference iof imindfulness iamong iadult ifemales iperforming iPilates ivs iaerobics

Keywords

imindfulness; iawareness; iposture; ifemale; igoals

Introduction

Pilates iis ia iform iof iexercise iwhich imainly ifocuses ion iphysical istrength, iposture iand iintensify imental iawareness iby iusing icustomized iapparatus. iNow-a-days iPilates inot ionly iused ias ifitness itraining ibut ialso ias ia irehabilitation itool isuch ias iin imusculoskeletal idisorders, ilow iback ipain, imultiple isclerosis, iosteoporosis iand imany imore. iPilates iis inot ionly irecommended ias ia icomplete irehabilitation iprocess ibut iit ican ialso iimprove ithe iphysical ihealth.[1]

It ihave iboth iphysical iand ipsychological ieffects. iIt ican ibe idone iby icustomized iapparatus ior iby imats i(specially idesigned ifor iPilates ior iyoga ipurpose).it iis ia ilow iimpact iexercise iwhich iis ieffective ito itone iup ithe ibody iand ibuild iup ithe ilean ibody iMass. iPeople idemand ifor iphysical ifitness ibecause iof ithe itreatment icost iof isome idisorders ito ilower ithe ifinancial iburden i.most iof ithe iresearch iproposes ithat ihealth irelated iissues iand ipain ireduces iby iexercise. iPilates iis ia ilow-impact ianaerobic iexercise ithat iaims ito istrengthen imuscles iwhile iimproving ipostural ialignment iand iflexibility. iPilates imainly itargets ithe icore, ialthough ithe iexercises iwork iother iareas iof iyour ibody ias iwell. iYou ican ido iPilates iwith ior iwithout iappliances i(more ion ithat ibelow), ibut ino imatter iwhat, iexpect ithe imoves ito iinvolve islow, iprecise imovements iand ibreathing iexercise. i"Pilates iis ifull-body iexercise imethods ithat iwill ihelp iyou ido ieverything ibetter," iSonja iHerbert, ia iPilates iinstructor iand ifounder iof iBlack igirl iPilates, itells iSELF. i"It istrengthens iand istabilizes iyour icore ibody, iwhich iis iyour ifoundation, iso ithat iyou ican imove iefficiently iwhile iimproving iyour iposture, iflexibility, iand imobility." iA itypical iPilates iworkout iis i45 iminutes ito ian ihour ilong.[2]

Aerobics iis ienergy iconsumption iexercise iwhich ineeds ioxygen ito imeet iits irequirements. iIt iis ia ilow ito ihigh iintensity ibased i iexercise iincluding iswimming, icycling, irunning, ijogging, iwalking ietc.[3]This iexercise ineeds ia ilong iperiod iof itime iand imost iof ithe itime iin imoderate iintensity. iIt ireally ihelps ito icope iup iwith idifferent idiseases isuch ias icancer, iheart irelated idisease iand ilonger ithe ilife ispan. iAerobics is ia iform iof physical iexercise that icombines irhythmic aerobic iexercise with stretching and istrengthening routines iwith ithe igoal ito iboost iup iall ielements iof ifitness i(flexibilitymuscular strength, iand cardio-vascular fitness). iIt iis iusually iperformed ito imusic iand imay ibe ipracticed iin ia igroup isetting iled iby ian instructor (fitness iprofessional), ialthough iit ican ibe idone isolo iand iwithout imusical iaccompaniment. iWith ithe igoal iof ipreventing iillness iand ipromoting physical ifitness, ipractitioners iperform ivarious iroutines icomprising ia inumber iof idifferent idance-like iexercises. iFormal iaerobics iclasses iare idivided iinto idifferent ilevels iof iintensity iand icomplexity iand iwill ihave ifive icomponents: iwarm-up i(5–10 iminutes), icardiovascular iconditioning i(25–30 iminutes), imuscular istrength iand iconditioning i(10–15 iminutes), icool-down i(5–8 iminutes) iand istretching iand iflexibility i(5–8 iminutes). iAerobics iclasses imay iallow iparticipants ito iselect itheir ilevel iof iparticipation iaccording ito itheir ifitness ilevel. iMany igyms ioffer ia ivariety iof iaerobic iclasses. iEach iclass iis idesigned ifor ia icertain ilevel iof iexperience iand itaught iby ia icertified iinstructor iwith ia ispecialty iarea irelated ito itheir iparticular iclass. iIt iis ireally ihelpful ifor imeditation ipurpose iand ifor istress ireduction. iIt ihas ibeen iobserved ithat ipeople iinvolved iin iaerobics ihave ivery ifresh iand iactive iminds ithan ithose iwho iare inot iinvolved iin iaerobics. iIt iwork iwonders ifor iobese ipeople ibecause iit iis ireally ibeneficial ifor iquick iweight iloss. iIts i8 iweek iMSRB ishows ireally ieffective iresults ion isedentary ilifestyle. iit ialso iprevents ithe iinfection iof irespiration.[4]

Mindfulness iis ithe ibasic ihuman iability ito ibe ifully ipresent, iaware iof iwhere iwe iare iand iwhat iwe’re idoing, iand inot ioverly ireactive ior ioverwhelmed iby iwhat’s igoing ion iaround ius. iMindfulness iis ia iquality ithat ievery ihuman ibeing ialready idominates, iit’s inot isomething iyou ihave ito ievoke, iand iyou ijust ihave ito ilearn ihow ito iaccess iit. iMindfulness iis ithe ibasic ihuman iability ito ibe ifully ipresent, iaware iof iwhere iwe iare iand iwhat iwe’re idoing, iand inot ioverly ireactive ior ioverwhelmed iby iwhat’s igoing ion iaround ius. iMindfulness iis ito ibe ifocused ion isomething iyou iare isaying ior ilistening ior iseeing, ithinking iand iyou iare ipresent imentally iin ia iparticular isituation. iYou ishould iaccept ithe iother iperson’s iperspective iand ibe iable ito idefine iyour iperspective. iYou iare imentally iactive ievery itime ievery isingle iminute ievery isingle ihour ithat’s imindfulness.[3]

Mindfulness ican ibe iincreased iby imeditation. iMeditation iis isomething ithat irelaxes ithe imind iand ibody iand ican ihelp ia iperson ito iperform ihis/her itasks ieasily iin itheir idaily ilife. imost iof ithe itime iit ican ibe iachieved iby iyoga ibecause iyoga ican ienhance ithe ieffects iof imindfulness iand iin ithe icurrent icentury ipeople iare ireally ibusy iin itheir iwork iso ithey ican’t iget itime ifor ithemselves iso itry ito imake itime i ifor ithemselves iby imeans iof iyoga, iPilates, iaerobics ito irelax itheir imind iand ibody iand iit iis ithe ibest iway ito ibe istress ifree.[5]

Everything icomes iwith iits ipros iand icons iPilates iand iaerobics ihave iuncountable iadvantages ilike iPilates iimproves iflexibility, iit iincrease imuscle itone iand istrength ispecially ibuttocks, iabdominal iand ilower iback imuscle, iit ialso ibalanced imuscular istrength iit iimprovise ithe imuscle icontrol iit iimproved istabilization iof iyour ispine iimproved iposture irehabilitation iof iinjuries irelated ito imuscle iimbalance iit iincreased ilung icapacity iand icirculation ithrough ideep ibreathing iit ialso imanaged istress iand ipromote irelaxation, iimproved iconcentration iand ibody iawareness. iIt ialso ihelps iin iimproving iposture irelated iissues, istrengthens ithe ibody iand iworks ion ithe iendurance iof imuscle, iimproves icore istability, ienhances ithe imental iability, imakes ia iperson iphysically iand imentally iactive iand imakes ia iperson imore iaware iof itheir isurroundings. iIt ialso iimproves ibalance iand iflexibility. iIt iprevents islouching. iYou ihave ito itake iprecautions iwhile idoing iPilates iincluding ipeople iwho ihad irecent isurgery, ipregnant iwomen, ipeople iaged i40 ior imore, ipeople iwith iheart idisease iand imusculoskeletal iinjury iand idisorder, ianyone iwho iis inot iinvolve iin iexercise ifor ia ilong itime, iand ipeople iwho iare ivery iobese. iDisadvantaged iof iPilates iare ithat iit iis inot ithat ieffective ifor iweight iloss iand iwill inot iburn ithat imuch icalories iif iwe iwant ito iachieve iinstant ior iquick iresult iit iprogress islow iso ipeople inormally ifrustrate iPilates iare inot ireally ifor irehabilitation ilike iif iyou ihave ian iinjury iand iyou ijoin iPilates iclasses ionly ifor irehab ipurpose ithan iits inot ieffective iin iany iway ifor iinjury. iYou ihave ito ifollow isome iguideline ito iachieve iexpected iresults iand ihave ito ibe ifully ifocused iwhich iis inot ian ieasy itask.[6]

On ithe iother ihand iaerobics iincrease ithe iefficiency iof irespiration. iIt iimproves iblood ivolume, idistribution, iand idelivery ito imuscle. iIt iincrease icardiovascular iefficiency iand idecrease iresting iheart irate, istrengthen imuscle, iligaments, itendons iand ibones. iIt iimproves ithe iefficiency iof imovement. iIt iimproves ithe istroke ivolume, iincrease icardiac ioutput. iIt ihelps ireduce ithe irisk iof ideveloping icoronary iartery idisease, icancer iand idiabetes. iIt ihelps idecrease ianxiety iand istress iimproves ithe ibody’s iability ito iuse ibody ifat ias ienergy isource. iIt ihelps iu ifeel ibetter ioverall. iAerobics ireally igood ifor iheart irelated iissues iit icontrols ithe ihigh iblood ipressure iand ireduce ithe irisk iof idiabetes, iheart iattack iby ireducing ithe iwork ion iheart iand iblood ivessels. iIt ialso ienhances iour inervous isystem iit iimproves ifunction iof ibrain icells iand itries ito imake inew icells. iit iimproves ithe iquality iof isleep iif iyou itake ia i10 imin isession iof iaerobics idaily iit ilower ithe irisk iof isleep iapnea iand iyou ican itake ia ihealthy isleep iit ialso icomes iwith icons ilike ioveruse iinjuries ibecause iof irepetitive, ihigh-impact iexercise. iIt iis inot ieffective iin ibuilding imuscle imass. iOver itraining iif iyou iare icontinuously iworking iout ifor iseveral ihours iand inot itaking irest iyou iwill ibe imentally iand iphysically iexhausted. iOur ibody ialso ineeds itime ito irepair iitself ifrom ihectic iwork iif iwe iare idoing iwork iand iwork i iour ibody iwill ibecome itired iand iexcept iof ifeeling ienergetic iwe istart ifeeling ilow, iso iwe ihave ito itake icare iof ithe iroutine iand ischedule iof iour idaily iexercise ito ibe ifit iand imore ihealthy.[7]

The iprevalence iof ithis istudy iin iundergraduate ifemale iis i86% iand icommunity isample i66%[8]. i

Previous istudies iconcluded ithe ieffects iof imindfulness iamong ifemales iperforming iPilates iand iaerobics iseparately ibut ithere ithat ithere iwas ino icomparative istudy iheld ibefore iin iPakistan. iPilates iand iaerobics iboth ihave ia imassive ieffect ion imindfulness ias imentioned iin iall ithe iprevious istudies. iPeople ihad ino iawareness iabout ithe ieffects iof iPilates iand iprevious istudies iproposed ithat ithey ihave ishort iterm ieffects iso iwe iwant ito imake iaccurate ideclaration iregarding ithis ithat iwill ibe ibased ion iour istudy ifindings.[9]

Rationale

The istudy iwill ihelp ius ito idetermine ithe ieffect iof iPilates iand iaerobics ion imindfulness iand iwill ialso iprovide iawareness ito ithe igeneral ipopulation iabout ithe ieffects iof iPilates. iThis istudy iwill ieducate ipeople ithat ihow ito iovercome itheir istresses iand iprevent itheir ibody ifrom ivarious idiseases iby ilearning ithe ibenefits iof iPilates iand iaerobics. iBy iincorporating ithe ifindings iof ithis istudy iexercise iplans iwould ibe imodified.

Literature Review I

Karen iet ial ipublished ia iresearch iarticle ion i27 iDecember i2014. i iIn ithis istudy ithey iwant ito iobserve ithat iby itaking ipart iin imovement ibased iexercises ilike iPilates ior iyoga ior iaerobics ithe isleep iquality, imood, istress ireduces ior imay ihave ieffect ion imindfulness. iIt iincreases ior idecreases ithe ieffect ion imindfulness ior iwill ihelp iin ibetter isleep. iThis istudy iconcludes ithat imovement ibased iexercise ireduce idepression, ianxiety, ieating idisorders iand istress.[5]

Hector iet ial iconducted ia istudy iregarding imindfulness iand inon imindfulness ibased iexercises ion idepression iin iHong iKong. iIt imainly ifocuses ion ihow ito imanage idepression iby imindfulness iand inon imindfulness iexercises iand ihow iit ireduces ithe ieffect iof idepression. iTo iprolong ithe ieffects iof imindfulness idifferent itechniques iwere iused ias iwell ias ifor ilowering ithe irisk iof idepression. iThe iresult iindicates ithat ithey iare ieffective ifor ishort iterm ionly.[9]

Keira iet ial ipublished ia iresearch iarticle ion i26 iMarch i2017. iA istudy idefines iPilates works ias ia irehabilitation itool ibecause iin imost iof ithe istudies iit iwas iused ifor istretching iand ibreathing icontrol ipurpose. iThis istudy iwas ibasically iconducted ito iobserve ithe iother ibenefits iof iPilates iin idifferent idisorders irather ithan iin iphysical ifitness. iThis istudy ireflects ithat iit iis iuseful ito ireduce ipain iand idisability.[10]

Karl iet ial ipublished ia iresearch iarticle ithat iwas iapproved iin ithe iyear i2018 ion i12 iFebruary iwhich iwas ibased ion imental ihealth ioutcome. iThat idefines iPilates ican iimprove ior ihave ibetter ior iunknown ieffect ion idepression iand ianxiety. iThis istudy iconclude ithat ithey ihave icontrolled iemotions iand iincreases ipeace iof imind ithrough iPilates i.[11]

Hendrick iet ial ipublished ia iresearch iarticle ion i22 iFebruary i2014. iStudy imainly ifocuses ion ithe imen iwho iwere isuffering ifrom idifferent idiseases ilike icancer, iheart iproblem, ichronic ipain, idepression, i ipersonality idisorders iand ithe isessions iof iaerobics iwere iconducted ito isee ithe iresult iwhether iit ican iprevent ior iimprove itheir imental iand iphysical ihealth. iThis istudy ireveals ithat iregular iphysical iactivity imay ienhance ibody iawareness.[12]

Philippe iet ial ipublished ia iresearch iarticle iin iStanford iuniversity iwhich idescribe ihow ia iperson iimagine ihimself iand ithe iview iof ia iperson iabout ihis iown ipersonality, iwhether iit iis iin ipositive isense ior iin inegative iand i iby iperforming iaerobic iexercise ithe iperspective iabout iself iimage ichanges ior inot. iThe iresult iis ithat ithis istudy ineeds ifurther iresearch ito iconclude ithat i,it ineeds imore istress imanagement iprograms ifor ieffective iresults.[13]

Jacob iet ial ipublished ia iresearch iarticle ion i31 iMarch i2018. iThe istudy iwas ispecifically ipointed itowards i8 iweek ibenefits iof iaerobic itraining iand ithe istress ireduction iprogram. iResults iconcluded ithat iit ienhances ithe iphysical iand imental ihealth iof ia iperson iby ireducing ithe istress iand ialso iprevent iour ibody ifrom ivarious idiseases. iThis istudy iconclude ithat iapplication iof itwo iinterventions iare imore ibeneficial ito igot isatisfactory iresult ifor iphysical iactivity.[4]

Kristin iet ial ipublished ia iresearch iarticle ithat iwas iaccepted ion i20 iFebruary i2018. iThis istudy iwas imainly iconducted ifor ithe ifact ithat iwe iall iknow ithat imindfulness ichanges iand iimprovise ithe ihealth ibehavior ibut ithey iall iwanted ito iknow ithat iis ithere ianything ithey ican iimprove ifor ithe ibetterment iof isociety iand iwell ibeing iof ia iperson. iThe iresearch iresults iconcludes ithat isuch itype iof iinterventions ican ihelp ito iimprove ithe imindfulness iand ihealth ibehavior.[3]

Operational Definition

 Mindfulness

The i“mindfulness iattention iawareness iscale” iwas iused ito idetermine ithe icomparison iof iaerobics iand iPilates ion imindfulness iamong ithe iadult ifemales iof iLahore. iThe iquestionnaire iincludes i iquestions iabout ilevel iof iconsciousness, icarelessness, ifocused iimage, ipaying iattention, ifeeling iof idiscomfort, ilevel iof ialertness, ilack iof iinterest, iover ithinking, ipolyphagia. iThe iCronbach’s ialpha i(0.85).[1]

Mindfulness iattention iawareness iscale i(MAAS) iis ia ireliable itool ito idetermine ithe imindfulness ilevel. iTo iscore ithe isimply icomplete imean iof i15 iitems ihighest iscore ireflect ilevel iof idispositional imindfulness.

Objective

To icompare imindfulness ibetween ifemales iperforming iPilates ivs iaerobic iexercise

Materials Iand Methods

Study Design

A icomparative icross isectional istudy

Study Population

Females iperforming iPilates iand iaerobics i

Setting

Physiques ifitness igym

Synergy ifitness

Refuel igym

Physical ifitness iin icastle

Genesis

Shape iup@ARJ

Cuts igym

Fitness ifactory

ZS ifitness igym

Fitness itime igym

Right inow igym

Life ifitness iclub

Z

1.96

P

0.66

1-p

0.34

D

0.05

Study Duration

The istudy iduration iwas 6 imonths i

Sample isize

Sample isize iis icalculated ithrough ifollowing iformula iand iparameters

Text, letter

Description automatically generated

Sample isize icalculated iusing i66% iproportion iof ithe icondition iis i3

 Sampling Technique

Convenient isampling itechnique iwas iused.

 Ethical Issues

Data iwas icollected ifrom iall ithe ifemales iof iLahore iwho iwere iinvolved iin iPilates iand iaerobic iexercise iafter itaking itheir iconsent. iThe iethical icommittee iof iAzra iNaheed iMedical iCollage ihas iapproved ithe iexecution iof ithis istudy iin iGYM, is iof iLahore. iIt ihas ino iaffect ion ifemale’s iethical ivalues. iResearcher ihas ifollowed iall ithe iethics iof imedical ifield.

Eligibility criteria

Inclusion criteria

Data iwas igathered ifrom;

Adult ifemales iof i iLahore iranges ifrom i18 ito i50 iyears i

Exercise ion iregular ibasis i(3 itimes iper iweek ifor i50 imin)

Involved iin iaerobics i(cycling, itreadmill, iswimming)

Involved iin iPilates i(mat iexercises)

Exclusion Criteria

Data iwas inot igathered ifrom;

Recent isurgery

Unstable icardiovascular iconditions

Severe ihypertension

Acute iinfection

Pace imaker ior istunt

Menopause

Pregnant iwomen

 Data Collection Procedure

After getting ithe approval ifrom iphysiotherapy idepartment iof iAzra iNaheed iMedical iCollage ia icomparative icross isectional istudy iwas iconducted. iThe iparticipants ihave ifulfilled ithe iinclusion iand iexclusion icriteria. iTo igather idata iabout ithe imindfulness ilevel iof ithe ifemales iof iLahore iMAAS iquestionnaire iwas iused. iBy iforming itwo igroup iGroup iA iwith ifemales iinvolved iin iPilates i(mat iexercise) iand iGroup iB iwith ifemales iinvolved iin iaerobics i(cycling, irunning, ijogging, itread imill) iand ithey iall ihad ifollowed ithe iroutine i3 iday iper iweek ifor i50 imin. iThis ihas ibeen iassessed iby iMAAS iquestionnaire iit ihas imean iof i15 iitems iand ihigher ivalue iindicates idispositional imindfulness. Data Analysis

Data iwas ianalyzed iby iusing iSPSS iversion i21 iand iwas icalculated ithrough ithis isoftware. iFor icategorical ivariables ifrequency iand ipercentage iwas iused ifor idiscrete ivariables imean iand istandard ideviation iwas iused. iIndependent it itest iwas iused ito icompare ithe imindfulness ibetween itwo igroups iP-value iof i0.05 iconsidered isignificant.

Results

Table i1:: Study iGroup iof ithe iparticipants i

 

Frequency

Percent

Valid iPercent

Cumulative iPercent

PERFORMING iPILATES

187

54.0

54.0

54.0

PERFORMING iAEROBICS

159

46.0

46.0

100.0

Table i1 ishowing ithat iStudy iGroup iPERFORMING iPILATES iwere i54% iand iremaining iof ithe iparticipants iPERFORMING iAEROBICS iwere i46%S

Table i2 iMean iage iof ithe iparticipants

 

N

Minimum

Maximum

Mean

Std. iDeviation

age

346

16

42

24.00

4.845

Table i2 ishowing iMean iage iof ithe iparticipants iwas ifound i24 iyears

Table i3 iMASS iquestions iof ithe iparticipants

 

 

Almost iAlways

Very iFrequently

Somewhat iFrequently

Somewhat iInfrequently

Very iInfrequently

Almost iNever

I icould ibe iexperiencing isome iemotion iand inot ibe iconscious iof iit iuntil isome itime ilater

N=346

36

73

92

48

51

46

%age i

10.4

21.1

26.6

13.9

14.7

13.3

I ibreak ior ispill ithings ibecause iof icarelessness, inot ipaying iattention, ior ithinking iof isomething ielse.

N=346

31

46

68

85

61

55

%age i

9

13.3

19.7

24.6

17.6

15.9

I ifind iit idifficult ito istay ifocused ion iwhat’s ihappening iin ithe ipresent.

N=346

32

48

54

74

96

42

%age i

9.2

13.9

15.6

21.4

27.7

12.1

I itend ito iwalk iquickly ito iget iwhere iI’m igoing iwithout ipaying iattention ito iwhat iI iexperience ialong ithe iway.

N=346

32

48

44

105

63

54

%age i

9.2

13.9

12.7

30.3

18.2

15.6

I itend inot ito inotice ifeelings iof iphysical itension ior idiscomfort iuntil ithey ireally igrab imy iattention.

N=346

28

49

53

67

71

78

%age i

8.1

14.2

15.3

19.4

20.5

22.5

I iforget ia iperson’s iname ialmost ias isoon ias iI’ve ibeen itold iit ifor ithe ifirst itime.

N=346

24

46

70

73

43

90

%age i

6.9

13.3

20.2

21.1

12.4

26

It iseems iI iam i“running ion iautomatic,” iwithout imuch iawareness iof iwhat iI’m idoing.

N=346

16

31

67

91

69

72

%age i

4.6

9

19.4

26.3

19.9

20.8

I irush ithrough iactivities iwithout ibeing ireally iattentive ito ithem.

N=346

25

41

91

82

73

34

%age i

7.2

11.8

26.3

23.7

21.1

9.8

I iget iso ifocused ion ithe igoal iI iwant ito iachieve ithat iI ilose itouch iwith iwhat iI’m idoing iright inow ito iget ithere.

N=346

26

51

54

67

91

57

%age i

7.5

14.7

15.6

19.4

26.3

16.5

I ido ijobs ior itasks iautomatically, iwithout ibeing iaware iof iwhat iI'm idoing.

N=346

22

24

60

91

57

92

%age i

6.4

6.9

17.3

26.3

16.5

26.6

I ifind imyself ilistening ito isomeone iwith ione iear, idoing isomething ielse iat ithe isame itime.

N=346

22

37

63

67

109

48

%age i

6.4

10.7

18.2

19.4

31.5

13.9

I idrive iplaces ion i‘automatic ipilot’ iand ithen iwonder iwhy iI iwent ithere.

N=346

11

32

53

74

106

70

%age i

3.2

9.2

15.3

21.4

30.6

20.2

I ifind imyself ipreoccupied iwith ithe ifuture ior ithe ipast.

N=346

18

21

68

95

89

55

%age i

5.2

6.1

19.7

27.5

25.7

15.9

I ifind imyself idoing ithings iwithout ipaying iattention.

N=346

10

36

68

62

102

68

%age i

2.9

10.4

19.7

17.9

29.5

19.7

I isnack iwithout ibeing iaware ithat iI’m ieating.

 

N=346

13

48

35

66

95

89

%age i

3.8

13.9

10.1

19.1

27.5

25.7

Table i3 ishowing iMASS iquestions iof ithe iparticipants

Table i4 iMean itotal iMASS iscore iand iaverage iscore

 

N

Minimum

Maximum

Mean

Std. iDeviation

Total iScore(sum) i iout iof i90

346

31

81

59.53

10.709

Average iscore(sum/15) iout iof i6

346

2.1

5.4

3.968

.7186

Table i4 ishows ithat iMean itotal iMASS iscore iwas ifound i59.5 iout iof i90 iand imean iaverage iscore iwas ifound i3.97 iout iof i6 iwhich iindicates ithat iparticipants ihave iabove iaverage idispositional imindfulness i

Table i5 iIndependent isample it itest ifor istudy igroup imatching ion ithe ibasis iof i iage

P ivalue i.842

 

Study iGroup

N

Mean

Std. iDeviation

Std. iError iMean

Age

PERFORMING iPILATES

187

24.05

4.557

.333

PERFORMING iAEROBICS

159

23.94

5.178

.411

Table i5 ishows iIndependent isample it itest ifor istudy igroup imatching ion ithe ibasis iof iage. iThere iwas inon-significant idifference ibetween igroups iPERFORMING iPILATES iand iaerobics ion ithe ibasis iof iage i(p=.842)

Table i6 iIndependent isample it itest ito isee ithe idifference iof imindfulness iamong iwomen iperforming iPilates iand iaerobics

P ivalue i.228

Table i6 iis ishowing iIndependent isample it itest ito isee ithe idifference iof imindfulness iamong iwomen iperforming iPilates iand iaerobics. iThere iwas ifound inon-significant idifference iof iaverage imindfulness iscore ibetween itwo igroups. iAlthough igroups iinvolved iin iPERFORMING iPILATES ihave islightly imore iaverage imindfulness iscore. i

Discussion

A icomparative icross isectional istudy iconducted ion ifemales iperforming iPilates iand iaerobics iwith ipopulation iof i346. iThe iprevalence iof ithe istudy igroup iperforming iPilate iwere i54% iand iremaining iof ithe iparticipants iperforming iaerobics iwere i46%. iMAAS iquestionnaire iwas iused ito iassess ithe imental iawareness, ifocus iand iover ireactive ior ioverwhelmed iresponses.

iTotal i346 ifemales iwere iselected ifrom idifferent igyms ito ievaluate ithe imindfulness ilevel. iThe ipercentage iof ifemales iperforming iPilates iis islightly ihigher ithan ithe ifemales iperforming iaerobics. iMean iage iof ithe iparticipants iwas ifound i24 iyears. iMean itotal iMASS iscore iwas ifound i59.5 iout iof i90 iand imean iaverage iscore iwas ifound i3.97 iout iof i6 iwhich iindicates ithat iparticipants ihave iabove iaverage idispositional imindfulness. iIndependent isample iT itest iwas iused ifor istudy igroup imatching ion ithe ibasis iof iage. iThere iwas inon-significant idifference ibetween igroups iperforming iPilates iand iaerobics ion ithe ibasis iof iage i(p=.842)

Independent isample it itest iused ito isee ithe idifference iof imindfulness iamong iwomen iperforming iPilates iand iaerobics. iThere iwas ifound inon-significant idifference iof iaverage imindfulness iscore ibetween itwo igroups. iAlthough igroups iinvolved iin iperforming iPilates ihave islightly imore iaverage imindfulness iscore ishowing ip ivalue i228.

A iprevious istudy iconducted iin i2018 iby iAlison ithat iwas ia iphenomenological istudy ito ifind iout ithe irelation iof iPilates ito iphysical iand imental iawareness. iShe isuggested ithat iPilates iis ioriginally icalled i“contrology” icreated iby iJoseph iHubertus iPilates iin ithe i1920s ifor irehabilitation. iPilates iis ito iachieve ifull ibody icoordination, imind iand ispiritually. iShe iwants ito ifind iout iwhether ia idaily ipractice iof iPilates iin imy iwork ior iresting iincrease iawareness iphysically iand imentally. iShe iresearched ion iLBP iand ibody iawareness. iHer iresults ishowed ithat iLBP ireduce isignificantly iby iperforming iPilates idaily. iShe idescribe ithat ibefore iperforming iPilates iwhen ishe isaw iher iin ithe imirror ishe ionly ifound iimperfections ibut inow iwhen ishe isaw iherself ishe ifound ito ibe iconfident iand istrong iand ihad ipositive iimage iabout iher iideal ibody. iThis istudy iresults icontradict iwith iour istudy iresults iin ia iway iit idoesn’t iput iemphasis ion imindfulness iwith iaerobics.[14]

Another istudy iwas iconducted ito iassess ithe ieffects iof imindful iand inon-mindful iexercise iamong ipeople iwith idepression ia irandomized istudy iwas iconducted iamong ithe isample iwas itaken ipeople iaged i18 ior iabove iand ithe iresults ishowed ithat iboth imindful iand inon-mindful iexercise iwere ieffective ifor ishort iterm. iThis istudy ihas ilimitations iso ithat ithey irecommended ithat iwell-controlled istudies ishould ibe iconduct iin ifuture ito ievaluate ithe ishort iand ilong iterm ieffects iof iexercise. iThis istudy isupports iour istudy iin ia iway ithat iaerobics ihave isignificant ibut ishort iterm ieffect ion imindfulness[9]

A iqualitative istudy iwas iconducted ito ievaluate ithe iPilates iand imindfulness irelation. iHe itook ithe isample ifrom iPilates iclass iwith ia icertified iinstructor iand imade i15 ito i18 istudents ito iparticipate iin ithis iprogram ievery ithree idays ifor i50 iminutes. iThis istudy iconcluded ithat istudents iwere iconnected iway imore iwith ieach iother, ibody iawareness iincreases, iability ito iconcentrate iand iconfidence iincreases iand irisk iof iinjury idecreases. iThis istudy isupports iour istudy iresult ithat iPilates ihas isignificant ieffect ion imindfulness.[6]

Another istudy iwas iconducted ito idetermine ithe icomparison iof iMBSR ivs iaerobics. iThe istudy iwas iabout iSAD ito iexamine iwhich ione ihas imore ieffects ito iovercome isocial ianxiety. iIt iwas ia irandomized istudy iwith ififty isix iadult ipatients. iA iself-referential iencoding itask iwas iused ito iexamine ithe ichanges. iThe iresult iof ithis istudy iconcluded ithat iMBSR ihas imore isignificant ieffects ion iSAD ipatients ithan iaerobics. iThis istudy icontradict iwith ipresent istudy iin ia iway ithat iaerobics ihas iless isignificant iresults ithan iMBSR.[13]

Another iprevious istudy ion ideveloping imindfulness iamong icollege istudents ithrough imovement ibased icourses ithat istudy iinclude istudents iof itheir i2007_2008 isession iin i15 iweek iPilates iclasses. iThey iconcluded ithat ibeing iinvolved iin imovement ibased iprogram ioverall imindfulness iscore iincrease iit ialso iimproves isleep iquality, imood, iself-efficacy iand istress. iThis istudy isupport iour istudy idirectly ibecause imindfulness iincrease iby iperforming iPilates.[5]

Conclusion

This istudy iconcluded ithat iPilates iand iaerobics iboth ihave isignificant ieffects ion imindfulness. iAge ihave inon-significant ieffects ion imindfulness iin ifemales iand ithere iwas ifound inon-significant idifference iof iaverage imindfulness iscore ibetween itwo igroups. iAlthough igroups iinvolved iin iperforming iPilates ihave islightly imore iaverage imindfulness iscore. iThe imean iage iis i24. iThis istudy iconcluded ithat ithere iis inon-significant idifference iof imindfulness iadult ifemales iperforming iPilates ivs iaerobics.

Limitation and  Recommendation Limitation      

It iwas idifficult ito ifind ifemale i iparticipants iwho iwere ionly iengage iin i iPilates ior iaerobics imost iof ithe ithem iwere idoing iPilates iand iaerobics iboth i iso iit iwas icomplex ito ifilter ithem. i

Gyms idon’t iallow ius ito icollect idata.

         iParticipants iwere inot icooperative idue ito itheir ibusy iroutines.

Recommendation

The istudy ishould ibe iconducted ion inational ilevel iin iPakistan.

 iA iresearch ishould ibe iconducted ithat iincludes ipregnant iwomen iand ithose iwho ihave imenopause ifor imore isignificant iresults.

More iresearches ishould ibe iconducted iin ifuture ito ievaluate ithe ishort iand ilong iterm ieffects iof iPilates iand iaerobics i

Declaration

This is our original research work.

References

  1. Shipton, iE.A., iPhysical itherapy iapproaches iin ithe itreatment iof ilow iback ipain. iPain iand itherapy, i2018. i7(2): ip. i127-137.
  2. Bird, iA.S., iThe iPilates iMethod iand iIts iRelationship ito iPhysical iand iMental iAwareness: iA iPhenomenological iStudy. i2017, iAppalachian iState iUniversity.
  3. Horan, iK.A. iand iM.B. iTaylor, iMindfulness iand iself-compassion ias itools iin ihealth ibehavior ichange: iAn ievaluation iof ia iworkplace iintervention ipilot istudy. iJournal iof iContextual iBehavioral iScience, i2018. i8: ip. i8-16.
  4. Meyer, iJ.D., iet ial., iBenefits iof i8-wk imindfulness-based istress ireduction ior iaerobic itraining ion iseasonal ideclines iin iphysical iactivity. iMedicine iand iscience iin isports iand iexercise, i2018. i50(9): ip. i1850.
  5. Caldwell, iK., iet ial., iDeveloping imindfulness iin icollege istudents ithrough imovement-based icourses: ieffects ion iself-regulatory iself-efficacy, imood, istress, iand isleep iquality. iJournal iof iAmerican iCollege iHealth, i2010. i58(5): ip. i433-442.
  6. Adams, iM., iet ial., iPilates iand imindfulness: ia iqualitative istudy. iJournal iof iDance iEducation, i2012. i12(4): ip. i123-130.
  7. Lengacher, iC.A., iet ial., iRandomized icontrolled itrial iof imindfulness‐based istress ireduction i(MBSR) ifor isurvivors iof ibreast icancer. iPsycho‐Oncology: iJournal iof ithe iPsychological, iSocial iand iBehavioral iDimensions iof iCancer, i2009. i18(12): ip. i1261-1272.
  8. Mayer, iB., iM.G. iPolak, iand iD. iRemmerswaal, iMindfulness, iInterpretation iBias, iand iLevels iof iAnxiety iand iDepression: iTwo iMediation iStudies. iMindfulness, i2019. i10(1): ip. i55-65.
  9. Tsang, iH.W., iE.P. iChan, iand iW. iCheung, iEffects iof imindful iand inon‐mindful iexercises ion ipeople iwith idepression: ia isystematic ireview. iBritish iJournal iof iClinical iPsychology, i2008. i47(3): ip. i303-322.
  10. Byrnes, iK., iP.-J. iWu, iand iS. iWhillier, iIs iPilates ian ieffective irehabilitation itool? iA isystematic ireview. iJournal iof ibodywork iand imovement itherapies, i2018. i22(1): ip. i192-202.
  11. Fleming, iK.M. iand iM.P. iHerring, iThe ieffects iof ipilates ion imental ihealth ioutcomes: iA imeta-analysis iof icontrolled itrials. iComplementary itherapies iin imedicine, i2018. i37: ip. i80-95.
  12. Mothes, iH., iet ial., iRegular iaerobic iexercise iincreases idispositional imindfulness iin imen: ia irandomized icontrolled itrial. iMental iHealth iand iPhysical iActivity, i2014. i7(2): ip. i111-119.
  13. Goldin, iP., iet ial., iRandomized icontrolled itrial iof imindfulness-based istress ireduction iversus iaerobic iexercise: ieffects ion ithe iself-referential ibrain inetwork iin isocial ianxiety idisorder. iFrontiers iin ihuman ineuroscience, i2012. i6: ip. i295.
  14. Bird, iA.S., iThe iPilates iMethod iand iIts iRelationship ito iPhysical iand iMental iAwareness. i2018, iAppalachian iState iUniversity.