10 Young Cases of Accomodative Spasm in Turkey

Authors

Goksu Alacamli1*, Aylin Karalezli2
1Trakya University, Faculty of Medicine, Education and Research Hospital, Ophthalmology Departmant, 22000,Edirne, Turkey.
2Karalezli Private Ophthalmology Clinic, 48000, Mugla, Turkey.

Article Information

*Corresponding Author: Goksu Alacamli, Trakya University, Faculty of Medicine, Education and Research Hospital, Ophthalmology Departmant, 22000,Edirne, Turkey.

Received Date: August 08, 2023
Accepted Date: October 18, 2023
Published Date: December 04, 2023

Citation: Goksu Alacamli, Aylin Karalezli. (2023) “10 Young Cases of Accomodative Spasm in Turkey”, Ophthalmology and Vision Care, 4(1); DOI: 10.61148/2836-2853/JOVC/042.
Copyright: © 2023 Goksu Alacamli. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Abstract

Background: Spasm of near reflex; is a rare disorder involving esotropia, accomodative spasm leading to pseudo-myopia and intermittent and variable episodes of pupillary myosis. It is usually of functional origin and is most common in young patients.

Aims: To point out the first case serie of accomodative spasm in Turkey, involving 10 young cases.

Methods: Between 2014 and 2022, the files of the who had blurred vision, moderate or high level of myopia in autorefractometer values and were found to have emmetropic or mild hyperopia in cycloplegic drop examination were retrospectively analyzed. All the cases did not have any organic or travmatic history of clinics.

Results: The ages of our cases ranged from 5 to 20 years old. All the cases were girl. All cases had been diagnosed by Psychiatry Clinics as psychogenic and hysteria background, had pseudo-myopia and emetropic cycloplegic refraction.
Conclution: Spasm of near reflex or accomodative spasm is a rare clinic presentation. Clinicians should always bring this clinic to their mind if a young girl complaints about blurred vision and pseudo-myopia. Clinicians should avoid unnecessary tests to this cases.

Keywords

cycloplegic refraction; psychotherapy; accommodation spasm; blurred vision; spasm of near reflex

Introduction:
Spasm of the near reflex; is a rare disorder involving esotropia, pseudo-myopia and intermittent and variable episodes of pupillary myosis triad. It is usually of functional origin and is most common in young patients. Spasm of the near reflex causes by excess and involuntary accomodative spasm. In the cases of spasm of the near reflex, sometimes  cases have all the findings; esotropia, pseudo-myopia and myosis which make up the triad of near reflex spasm but sometimes only one or two of the findings of the the triad can be found in the cases. Especially, when only pseudo-myopia is seen in the cases of spasm of the near reflex, this clinic situation can be called only 'Accomodative Spasm'. Although there are organic, functional and traumatic causes among the reasons, the reason is mostly functional in mostly young and female cases. The fact that the cause is not due to a traumatic or organic cause can easily be understood by an experienced clinician with a simple history or a brief review of the laboratory results of the patient's previous referrals. In this way, many laboratory and radiological tests would be avoided. When it is understood that the cause is functional, this is usually because of hysteria, anxiety or depression. Treatment options of accomodative spasm or spasm of the near reflex have varying success. In cases where the etiology of spasm is suspected to be hysteria, anxiety or depression, the benefit of psychotherapy has been proven [1-8].

In published case reports or case series; cycloplegic drugs, negative or positive lenses, miotics, special concealing glasses, narcotherapy, psychotherapy in recent publications treatments have been reported to be effective in the treatment of accomodative spasm. However, the effects of these treatments are variable [2-11].

Accomodative spasm is an uncommon and rare clinical picture. Generally, this picture has been reported as a single case or small series since the start of 1900s (1-8,10-12). Symptoms in this clinic situation, in order of frequency in various series; blurred vision (71% -100%), diplopia (62%), headache (24% -56%), ocular pain (37% -47%),  photophobia (24%) were reported [1-13]. In routine clinical practice, in the absence of any ocular pathology, strabismus or amblyopia, in young patients, it is aimed that they can see 20/20 in Snellen charts during refraction examination with the idea taken from the autorefractometer values about their refractive error, if contist. Although in the absence of any ocular pathology, strabismus or amblyopia, if the young patient can not see 20/20 during refraction examination despite the added lenses by the autorefractometre values, hysteria, anxiety or depression or malingering should be brought to mind by experienced clinicans [1-5,7].

 Methods:
Between 2014 and 2022, the files of the cases who applied to the Ophthalmology clinic of Mugla Education and Research Hospital and who had not used or prescribed any glasses before, had visual impairment for a recent or medium period, had moderate or high level of myopia in autorefractometer values, could not see complete (20/20) in refraction examination and and who were found to have emmetropic or mild hyperopia in cycloplegic drop examination were retrospectively analyzed. All the cases did not have any organic or travmatic history of clinics. All about the cases included to this retrospective study had normal biomicroscopy and fundus examination.

This retrospective study was performed in accordance with the tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki and with the approval of the ..........................University Medical School of Medicine Ethics Committee (Registration Number: E-72855364-050.01.04-265101).
Results:

We had 10 young female cases who fit these features. The ages of our cases ranged from 5 to 20 years old. All the cases complaint about blurred vision. No case had diplopia, headache, ocular pain, photophobia. All the cases had pseudomyopia. Esotrpia and myosis was not seen in our cases. Blurred vision could not be corrected by added lens which are referred from autorefractometre. After cycloplegia, emetropia or mild hyperopia was seen in all cases. All in our cases, the reason of accomodative spasm was about hysteria, anxiety or depression caused by some of their problems about their family or school. All of them was referred to Psychiatric Clinics due to have the benefit of psychotherapy. In order to avoid involuntery and unnecessary accomodative spasm which lead to pseudo-myopia, short acting cycloplegic drugs were prescribed to all cases (Table1).

Discussion:
Pure accommodative spasm or spasm of near reflex has been tried to be presented with both case report and case series since the early 1900s from all over the world [1-8,10-12].

While there are studies published in the form of single case reports rather than case series in Turkey, in our first case series study in our country, we have seen that all cases had been diagnosed by Psychiatry Clinics as psychogenic and hysteria background, had pseudo-myopia and emetropic cycloplegic refraction. The ages of our cases ranged from 5 to 20 years old. All the cases were girl. In literature, most of the cases were girls too [1-13].

Problems that do not make much sense for adults may cause anxiety in children, especially girls. Significant differences before and after cycloplegia should suggest possible anxiety or depression in these children or young adults, and these cases should be referred to the relevant Psychiatric Clinics. Ophthalmologist should avoid unnecessary lab or radiology tests.

There are different recommendations for the treatment of accomadation spasm.
Long and short acting cycloplegic agents are widely used by other authors [1-8,9-11]. Atropine reduces the accommodation spasm by causing paralysis in the ciliary muscle, but it has some side effects [1,2,4,7,12,13]. We prescribed short acting cycloplegic agents (Tropicamide %0,5, 1x1) before they go to sleep, especially who had not the benefit of psychotherapy in short time, but they adviced not to stop the follow up by psychiatry clinics. In order to avoid the side effects of tropicamide, we preferred %0,5, rather than %1.

Accomodative spasm is not an easy clinic situation to treat unfortunately, because of its' functional origin. This patients should be under the control of both opthalmology and psychiatry departments. Anxiety or depression are not easily be treated by psychiatry clinics, and needs always a long time for treatment. In addition to advices of psychiatry departments to our cases, we also adviced them to take sun light more than usual by the fact that sunlight increases dopamine activity which leads to decrease depressive symptoms, anhedonia, fatigue, and psychomotor retardation [14,15,16].

Case Number
Age
Sex
Symptom
Spherical Equivalent Before Cycloplegic Drugs
Spherical Equivalent After Cycloplegic Drugs
Reason of

  Anxiety Disorder
Treatment

 
1
13
Female
Blurred Vision
R:-6,00
L:-6,25 
R:-0,50
L-0,75
Domestic violence

 
Psychotherapy and Cycloplegic Drugs
2
20
Female
Blurred Vision
R:-4,25
L:-6,25
R:+0,25
L:+0,25
Family Unrest
Psychotherapy and Cycloplegic Drugs
3
7
Female
Blurred Vision
R:-9,50
L:-9,50
R:+0,25
L:+0,25
Conflict With Her Teacher At School

 
Psychotherapy and Cycloplegic Drugs
4
5
Female
Blurred Vision
R:-3,50
L:-3,50
R:+0,75
L:+0,75
Conflict With Her Teacher At School

 
Psychotherapy and Cycloplegic Drugs
5
20
Female
Blurred Vision
R:-4,50
L:-4,50
R:+0,25
L:+0,25
Family Unrest
Psychotherapy and Cycloplegic Drugs
6
10
Female
Blurred Vision
R:-9,50
L:-5,50
R:+1,00
L:+0,75
Conflict With Brother At Home
Psychotherapy and Cycloplegic Drugs

 
7
13
Female
Blurred Vision
R:-3,50
L:-3,50
R:+1,00
L:+0,75
Conflict With Sister At Home
Psychotherapy and Cycloplegic Drugs

 
8
11
Female
Blurred Vision
R:-4,50
L:-5,50
R:+0,75
L:+0,75
Unhappiness At School

 
Psychotherapy and Cycloplegic Drugs

 
9
11
Female
Blurred Vision
R:-8,50
L:-7,50
R:+0,75
L:+0,75
Her Father Passed Away

 
Psychotherapy and Cycloplegic Drugs

 
10
12
Female
Blurred Vision
R:-5,50
L:-5,50
R:+0,50
L:+0,50
Unhappiness At Home

 
Psychotherapy and Cycloplegic Drugs

 
Table1: Demographic Characteristics Of our Patients

References

  1. Goldstein JH, Schneekloth BB. Spasm of the near reflex: a spectrum of anomalies. Surv Ophthalmol. 1996 Jan-Feb;40(4):269-78.
  2. Bharadwaj SR, Roy S, Satgunam P. Spasm of Near Reflex: Objective Assessment of the Near-Triad. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2020 Jul 1;61(8):18.
  3. Peinado GA, Merino Sanz P, Del Cerro Pérez I, Gómez de Liaño Sánchez P. Unilateral accommodation spasm: Case report and literature review. Arch Soc Esp Oftalmol. 2019 Jun;94(6):285-287. English, Spanish.
  4. Joel Hyndman (2018) Spasm of the Near Reflex: Literature Review and Proposed Management Strategy, Journal of Binocular Vision and Ocular Motility, 68:3, 78-86, 
  5. Rhatigan M, Byrne C, Logan P. Spasm of the near reflex: A case report. Am J Ophthalmol Case Rep. 2017 Feb 20;6:35-37.
  6. Christoff A, Christiansen SP. Spasm of the near reflex: treatment with miotics revisited. Am Orthopt J. 2002;52:110-3.
  7. Faucher C, De Guise D. Spasm of the near reflex triggered by disruption of normal binocular vision. Optom Vis Sci. 2004 Mar;81(3):178-81.
  8. Lind T, Atkinson S, Marsh JD. Diagnosis of Accommodative Spasm Aided by Handheld Photoscreener. J Binocul Vis Ocul Motil. 2020 Jan-Mar;70(1):37-39.
  9. Moore S, Stockbridge L, Another approach to the treatment of accomodative spasm. Am Orthopt J. 1973;23:71-2.
  10. Schwartze GM, McHenry LC Jr, Proctor RC. Convergence spasm--treatment by amytal interview. A case report. J Clin Neuroophthalmol. 1983;3:123-5.
  11. Rutstein RP, Daum KM, Amos JF. Accommodative spasm: a study of 17 cases. J Am Optom Assoc. 1988;59:527-38.
  12. Rutstein RP. Spasm of the near reflex mimicking deteriorating accommodative esotropia. Optom Vis Sci. 2000;77:344-6.
  13. von Noorden GK, Campos EC. Anomalies of convergence and divergence. Binocular Vision and Ocular Motility, 6th ed. St Louis; CV Mosby: 2002:500-7.
  14. Tsai HY, Chen KC, Yang YK, Chen PS, Yeh TL, Chiu NT, Lee IH. Sunshine-exposure variation of human striatal dopamine D(2)/D(3) receptor availability in healthy volunteers. Prog Neuropsychopharmacol Biol Psychiatry. 2011 Jan 15;35(1):107-10.
  15. Felger JC. The Role of Dopamine in Inflammation-Associated Depression: Mechanisms and Therapeutic Implications. Curr Top Behav Neurosci. 2017;31:199-219.
  16. Grace AA. Dysregulation of the dopamine system in the pathophysiology of schizophrenia and depression. Nat Rev Neurosci. 2016 Aug;17(8):524-32.